A closer look at a familiar choice

Peanut butter vs. Almond butter

Per 100 g, peanut butter, smooth style, without salt has 598 calories and 22.2 g protein; almond butter, plain, without salt added has 614 calories and 21 g protein. Change the basis to see the tradeoffs.

Choose a fair basis
APeanut butter100 g · USDA SR Legacy
vs.
BAlmond butter100 g · USDA SR Legacy
NutrientPeanut butterAlmond butter
Calorieskcal598614
Proteing22.221
Carbohydrateg22.318.8
Fatg51.455.5
Fiberg510.3
Total sugarsg10.54.4
Sodiummg177
Saturated fatg10.34.2

Values change with the amount you choose. A dash means the nutrient was not reported.

The difference at 200 calories.

Food amount

For 200 calories, the comparison uses 33.4 g of peanut butter and 32.6 g of almond butter.

Protein

Peanut butter provides more reported protein at equal calories: 7.4 g for peanut butter, compared with 6.8 g for almond butter.

Fiber

The fiber amounts are 1.7 g for peanut butter and 3.4 g for almond butter at 200 calories.

Sodium

At equal calories, the reported sodium amounts are 6 mg and 2 mg respectively. Added salt or a different brand can change this comparison.

Other choices to explore.

FoodBasisCaloriesProteinFiberSodium
Soy protein isolate, potassium typeUSDA SR Legacy100 g32188.3 g0 g50 mg
Soy protein isolateUSDA SR Legacy100 g33588.3 g0 g1,005 mg
Soy protein concentrate, produced by alcohol extractionUSDA SR Legacy100 g32863.6 g5.5 g3 mg